Is TYC 1722-557-1 a delta Scuti?

I’ve been playing around with the new photometry feature of the Seestar telescopes and have targeted U Peg the last couple days. Nice easy eclipsing binary to try out and learn the new feature. However I figured out that the app lets me log other variable stars in the field of view, so I did, for more than 5 hours each night. The last couple nights I noticed these oscillations in star TYC 1722-557-1.
I looked it up in the VSX (ASAS J235445+1501.5) and all I see is that it’s classified as a pulsating variable with a period of 21.3 days. I’m seeing 1.5 to 1.6 hour fluctuations. Could it be a delta Scuti? Should I submit a formal revision proposal to the VSX? I’ve never done one. thx. cmahar


2 Likes

The TESS light curve for that position shows what looks a delta Scuti star with multiple periods. There is no visual impression of a ~ 21 day oscillation.

1 Like

I should have added that the TESS light curve shown is only a small portion of the 27.88 day set of data from sector 56.

2 Likes

Asas-sn lists it as a HADS, high amplitude delta Scuti

2 Likes

A quick analysis in VStar using DC DFT shows two predominant pulsations.

2 Likes

Looks like a double-mode HADS, thus a HADS(B). Check if the period ratio is close to 0.77.
You already did your homework, so… is there anyone willing to submit a VSX revision combining ASAS-3, ASAS-SN and TESS data and giving the two pulsation periods (the one with the largest amplitude being the one that should go in the table. In the new VSX we will have as many available fields as needed to add other periods and variability types)?
This is an example of remarks, comments and plots needed for a HADS(B) submission.

Cheers,
Sebastian

1 Like

I redid the DC DFT in VStar using just the sector 56 TESS data with a tighter range of frequencies (14 to 24). The dominant frequency is 15.778 c/d and the second 20.446 c/d. The ratio is 0.772

1 Like

Inspired by the work so far, here is ASAS3, ASAS-SN, TESS data combined (additive load):

Note that I created a new series from the Johnson V loaded from ASAS (ASAS3).

I used the Magnitude and Time Shifter plug-in to move the TESS (TESS-SPOC) data to have the same mean magnitude as ASAS-SN.

I notice there’s also other data available, e.g. Catalina Sky Survey. Not sure whether this or others are worth adding.

0.063379 days, 15.778 cycles/day phase plots:

TESS:

ASAS3, ASAS-SN:

ASAS3, ASAS-SN, TESS:

It’s clear from this combined phase plot that there are different time units with TESS using BJD and ASAS/ASAS-SN using HJD. There’s a JD/HJD to BJD converter plug-in that I have not applied to ASAS/ASAS-SN.

0.048909 days, 20.446 cycles/day phase plots:

TESS:

ASAS3, ASAS-SN:

ASAS3, ASAS-SN, TESS:

David

Further to Sebastian’s comment, I’d be interested in collaborating with you all to prepare a VSX submission if that would help. I want to do more of this kind of thing, time permitting.

David

Thanks Roy for confirming it is a HADS(B), a star pulsating in both the fundamental mode and the first overtone, by calculating the period ratio.

And thanks David for your plots.

I’d like to give some tips to contribute with that submission.

One thing you need to keep in mind is that each survey has a different useful magnitude range (it is written in the VSX guidelines). CRTS saturates at mag. 13 so no CRTS data can be used to analyze this 11th mag. star.
ASAS-3, ASAS-SN and TESS are enough to cover more than 25 years so we don’t need anything else.

No, HJD and BJD won’t make a real difference for most projects. You will only see a very small difference with extremely short periods and tight light curves (not a double-mode pulsator).
The thing here is that you need to improve the period until all datasets provide a good match. The three datasets need to be analyzed together in order to get the best possible period. If you only analyze TESS, the time span of the data will be very short, so you won’t be able to take advantage of the very long time span that you have by combining all these data.
Your period of 0.063379 d is correct, but it can be improved to 0.06337887 d (two more decimal places).
When using this period we get this phase plot:

Also keep in mind that we need to determine an epoch of maximum or minimum when create plots, using random epochs is not useful. In order to determine an epoch (of maximum in this case), always use a real datapoint at maximum. Otherwise, if your period is off (even by a small amount), that error will propagate and the epoch you selected might end up very off too.

This is a final plot with an epoch of maximum and the correct period:

I won’t do the first overtone plot, but you should follow the same approach.

You will also be able to revise the magnitudes and give a range instead of a mean plus an amplitude like they are listed now. 10.89 - 11.09 V looks okay (the amplitude in the TESS infrared-like passband will always be smaller).

Let’s see what you get for the other mode!

Cheers,
Sebastian

1 Like

Hi Sebastian

Thanks for the feedback and useful commentary.

Here’s my equivalent of the plot you showed for the dominant:

and for the first overtone, I got a period of 0.04890882 with DCDFT:

It’s a little late here so I’ll look more closely at the magnitude range but I agree that looks reasonable.

David